That elusive release date for “Above Suspicion,” which wrapped 2 years ago in Kentucky

“Above Suspicion,” the movie, wrapped two years ago last month in the tiny eastern Kentucky mountain town of Harlan. The final day of the three-month shoot was bittersweet, in that the star of the movie, Emilia Clarke, had to rush off before dawn for a two-hour drive through the mountains of eastern Kentucky to board a connection for a flight for London to be at the bedside of her father, who died later in the day.

Movie wraps, especially after long shoots in less-than-commodious locations like the isolated old coal-town of Harlan, tend to be a bit like the last day of summer camp, with exchanges of emails and hugs among cast and crew who have been together day and night to make a movie. Emilia’s absence added a touch of sadness to the wrap party, but everyone had a sense even then that the indefatigable director Phillip Noyce had pulled it off, along with Clarke, her co-star Jack Huston, and a supporting cast including Johnny Knoxville, Thora Birch, Austin Hebert and Sophie Lowe. A congenial and very large crew worked from early mornings till late nights in a town with exactly one motel (a crammed-to-capacity Comfort Inn) and no bars or liquor stores (supply runs were launched to Tennessee, a two-hour drive over twisting mountain roads). By December 2017, the movie was finished, edited and scored and ready for distribution.

So where is the movie? Why do we have no information on a release date, which was supposed to have been last year and which is now noted on IMDB.com as merely “2018” (hey, it’s August and there is nothing scheduled) or, in various news accounts generated by the intense worldwide media interest in Emilia Clarke, as “forthcoming.”

I wrote the book and, as a consultant on the movie, I was on location for the final stretch of the shoot in Harlan. When I am asked about the release date, you would think I would have a better answer than, I simply don’t know. That’s embarrassing, frankly.

It’s important to know several things lest anyone assume this movie is not good enough for theatrical release. Jerry and Linda Bruckheimer (the wonderful and gracious Linda was on the set for most of the production of “Above Suspicion”) held screenings at their Beverly Hills home for industry executives and selected critics, including influential bloggers, The reviews and word of mouth were very enthusiastic. For example, Jeffrey Wells wrote this in “Hollywood Elsewhere:” “There have been a small handful of films that have  portrayed rural boondock types and their tough situations in ways that are honest and real-deal. My top three are John Boorman’s “Deliverance,” Billy Bob Thornton’s “Sling Blade” and Lamont Johnson’s “The Last American Hero,” [“Above Suspicion”] certainly deserves to stand side-by-side as a peer … Noyce always delivers with clarity and discipline but this is arguably the most arresting forward-thrust action flick he’s done since “Clear and Present Danger.” Plus it boasts s smart, fat-free, pared-down script by “Mississippi Burning’s” Chris Gerolmo, some haunting blue-tinted cinematography by Eliot Davis (“Out of Sight,” “Twilight”) and some wonderfully concise editing by Martin Nicholson.”

He added, “’Above Suspicion’ damn sure feels like an early ’70s film. I can tell you that. I mean that in the most complimentary way you could possibly imagine…

Where’s the movie, then? A couple of months ago, I had a Google Alert for “Above Suspicion” and “Emilia Clarke,” which led me to a website and fan forum on Clarke where there was a link to a pirated copy of the movie, dubbed in Turkish with the title “Suphe Otesi,” which basically translates into “Above Suspicion.” For the first time, I saw the movie. It is beautiful and gripping, even in Turkish, though of course it helped my comprehension that I had written the book and was a consultant, including on the screenplay.

TURKISH DVD COVER PIRATED
ABOVE: Cover for the evidently pirated Turkish language version of “Above Suspicion”

I immediately alerted my friend Colleen Camp, the executive producer of the movie, that a pirated print was available online. Within days the online link was removed by Google.

Since then, nothing — in English or Turkish. My frequent inquiries about the release date have met basically with radio silence from the producers.

I did, however, speak not long ago with Colleen Camp, a well-known actress and producer who tirelessly brought “Above Suspicion” from option two decades ago, to screenplay and casting and, finally, to production. Colleen was very frustrated with the delay and with what she described as squabbling among producers.

Having now had a little experience with the machinations of Hollywood, I know enough not to wade into the weeds of whatever the disputes are that have prevented a timely release of a movie that is generally regarded as a triumph. But here’s some of what Colleen told me:

“The movie is brilliant; it scored 98, but the system that we have now is that because of all the ancillaries, because of television rights and everything else, what happens is the studios, when they release a movie, they have other components that help cover the prints and ads, the P&A.” Essentially, she said, studios want to be able to follow a hit movie with television and other spinoffs.

I don’t quite understand why that is a snag, but it seems to be. In my opinion, it also seems to be something that should be easy to fix.

I understand that discussions with major distributors centered on a platform release, in which a movie is released to up to 600 theaters and then, assuming good reviews and word-of-mouth, released more widely. Distributing any movie requires millions in additional “P&A” money above the cost of actual production. With a major star like Clarke, a famed thriller director like Phillip Noyce and a pool of already enthusiastic word-of-mouth from those who have seen the movie at private screenings, that ought to be readily doable, I would think.

But the movie distribution business is changing. Colleen said that a major distributor told her that “Above Suspicion” looks to be ” a huge commercial hit, like Sherry Lansing’s “Fatal Attraction.” (Former Paramount chief Lansing produced the 1987 “Fatal Attraction,” which cost $14 million to make and grossed $163.5 million worldwide).

Today, distributors “want either big super-commercial [hits] like ‘The Avengers,’ or on the other end they want a ‘Lady Bird,’ she said. She described “Above Suspicion” as a “tweener” occupying ground between the giant franchise hits and the small hit independent movies like last year’s “Lady Bird,” which was budgeted at $10 million and grossed $77 million. The budget for “Above Suspicion” was about $12 million, plus another $8 to $12 million estimated for marketing and distribution, people connected with the production told me.

My guess is that a resolution of the  disputes is imminent and we’ll finally see at least an announcement this fall of a release date for “Above Suspicion.” And I am further guessing that the movie will be a hit and will be followed by a television series keyed to the movie but further exploring the plot of the book and its dark, dystopian setting in coal-mine eastern Kentucky, around the same time Ron Howard’s currently in-development “Hillbilly Elegy,” adapted from J.D. Vance’s runaway 2016 best-seller, comes out. I’m further guessing that the title for the TV series based on “Above Suspicion” will be “The Girl From Lonesome Holler,” which is a title I wished I had originally used for my book, published by Simon & Schuster in 1993.  A revised, updated edition of the book was published last year by Open Road Media. I researched the new epilogue right after leaving the set of the movie.

Colleen Camp, a real trouper who absolutely never gives up, says that all should fall into place before too long. “All I care about is, I want the movie marketed right,” she said.

###

22 comments

  1. I am sure when the movie comes out it will be excellent. Frustrating for many, who look forward to seeing it, that the wheels in Hollywood turn so slowly. I will keep watching for updates. Still, the book was such a page turner, I am glad I picked it up. I have to add that after I read it, my 3 brothers and my neighbor read it also.

    1. Jan, thanks for the comment, From what I hear, the movie is going to be great, Sure looked that way to me in the Turkish pirated version! Joe

      1. I am really interested in seeing the movie because I was on the grand jury of this case. I would like to see how the movie industry handles the story.

  2. Joe, I loved your book. I think it was brutal but honest. Hailing from Michigan, I spent seven years in Kentucky and fell in love with the people and the state – it’s very likely I’ll eventually retire there. As for the release? [Please properly affix your tin-foil hat NOW…] I wouldn’t doubt the FBI and DOJ have intervened and prevented this movie from releasing. Top brass at both institutions have been revealed to be corrupt to the core and public confidence in both groups has plummeted. They don’t want an “FBI murderer” movie out right now. I have no evidence or proof of this, beyond the absolute tomfoolery that has been exposed in the last 18 months. I’m just going to call it a “safe assumption.” Keep up the good work and I look forward to your next novel.

    1. Briana, Thanks for this. I had the same impression of eastern Kentucky, back when I wrote the book and then again when I revisited after the movie shoot. Gotta disagree with you about the FBI. My FBI sources were helpful when I wrote the book, though they had to be on background only. Then in 2017, during the movie shoot, Jim Huggins, the retired FBI supervisor whose unhappy lot it was to bring Mark Putnam to justice, was was enormously helpful in filling in gaps and some new background for the revised edition. The FBI, I think, learned from the mistakes in assigning a rookie like Putnam unsupervised to a place like the Pikeville office, and especially in the misuse of female informants like Susan Smith. It was a major blight on the Bureau, and they admit that. Thanks, Joe

  3. Jan, thanks for the comment, From what I hear, the movie is going to be great, Sure looked that way to me in the Turkish pirated version!

  4. Really looking forward to the release of this movie. It’s an amazing story. I live in Harlan County, Kentucky where the movie was filmed. Looking forward to seeing my little town on the big screen! Great job on the book sir.

  5. I’m very anxious and excited to see this film! I was fortunate enough to be cast as an extra (a defense attorney) and lived the thrill of of two days on the set. I was not aware of the story until filming and afterward read your excellent book. A very gripping tale! Can’t wait to see it on the big screen!

  6. Joe – thanks for keeping us all updated on the release status (IMDB should have a link to this site). One would think that with such an ensemble cast, excellent director, and good word of mouth that the industry stakeholders would cut through things and get this out during awards season (and that the actors would have some power over that).

    1. Thank you, Fred. I’m astonished — and at this point angry — that a movie that’s as good as the preview critics say is languishing unreleased, I think “Game of Thrones” has has finished production and I would guess that Emilia, who worked day and night on the shoot for three months along with Jack Huston and of course the indefatigable Phillip Noyce, has some open time for promotion of the movie. As I noted before, the FBI consultant Jim Huggins and I joked during the shoot that we could writing a book called “Beyond Belief: The Making of ‘Above Suspicion,'” and maybe that’s actually not a bad idea. Good idea about an IMDB link, incidentally.

  7. I was born and raised in Harlan County KY and have lived in Michigan for 34 years.. Thank you for filming in my hometown.. I ordered the book and enjoyed every page.. I can’t wait to see the movie.. If anyone hasn’t purchased the book they should.. what a sad story for both families..

  8. I am from Kentucky (Lexington area) and have a personal interest in this movie. My granddaughter is an extra in the movie, she is the little girl that plays Jack Hustons daughter. She was 3 at the time and she and her parents had an amazing experience during the filming. I love movies based on true events. We can’t wait to see the movie! Hope it’s soon!

    1. Jennifer, I remember how fond Emilia Clarke and Jack Huston were of the kids on the shoot. I can’t wait to see them all together when the movie (finally) gets released. Thanks for the note.

  9. Hello Joe, It has been a long time! I just finished reading Above Suspicion for the second time. First time was way back in the 90’s. I am amazed with how much I forgot but I am getting older and sometimes yesterday surprises me. Anyway, the epilogue was great along with the pictures. Putting a face to the names was really helpful. I am looking forward to the release of the movie; once Hollywood gets their ducks in order. Very well done!

  10. I saw this film in Poland at Camerimage with Mr Noyce and it is a truly exquisite film, the cinematography throughout is beautiful, it tweaks on the heartstrings and pulls you in to an experience that no matter how terrifying it may seem, you never want to live without

  11. Sounds like an awesome project. Will look forward to seeing it when it comes out. I’m with you that it’s hard to believe they would sit on something that scored so highly. Especially since the tenor of our culture changes with such rapidity. A 98 in 2017 may be an 85 in 2019, but I hope that is not the case. Will cross my fingers and say a prayer that it makes its when into the distribution channel adroitly and quickly 🙂

  12. Not only have I been patiently waiting for the release, I have been starved for info regarding the release. Not sure how I missed this in August, but it’s so good to hear something! Thanks for the update. Loved the book! Ordered the one about John List. Hope it is just as good!

    1. Monica, alas no release date yet. Many thanks for the note. I hope you got the new edition (updated last year) of my John List book and that you find it interesting. Best, Joe Sharkey

  13. I am writing a novel that partially takes place in a fictitious town in Pike County, Kentucky. The book, my first, is a psychological thriller. I traveled to the area and stayed at the Landmark Inn in Pikeville to research the area for my story. I wanted to get a feeling for the people, the topography of the surrounding mountains, the accent, food, and overall feeling of the area. In August, I booked the room at the Landmark with my two teenage daughters and we were shocked at the eerie feeling of the place after a long drive there from Morgantown, West Virginia. We had no idea about the story of Susan Smith when we arrived. A couple locals I met at the Landmark’s pool filled me in about her story. Fascinating! As soon as I got home to Pennsylvania, I saw the Kentucky Confidential episode on the show Perfect Suspect about Susan Smith’s story. I am looking forward to the movie and reading your book. A twist of irony is my oldest daughter had just visited West Virginia University as part of our getaway. She is considering going there to enroll in their amazing forensic program. Her goal is to eventually become an FBI agent. We were shocked to learn the story of FBI agent Mark Putnam spending some of his last hours with Susan right at the Landmark where we stayed. I had originally heard the movie was to come out in November, but now that date is no longer listed. We are awaiting its release with bated breath.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s